Problems arising from cascading taxation in the context of value added tax in Hungary
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32980/MJSz.2025.1.19Keywords:
value-added tax, real estate transfer tax, hybrid taxes, cascading taxation, excessive taxation, interference of taxesAbstract
The most important underlying rationale behind the construction of the EU value added tax (VAT) system was the replacement of the national cascading turnover tax systems that distorted the competition and prices for a neutral and common system in order to attain the objectives of the internal market. However, this objective has not been fully realized. The main reason for this is the persisting interference of national turnover / turnover-based business taxes with the VAT system in the context of the Hungarian tax system. The present contribution aims to demonstrate these problematic cases, with particular regard to the examination of such interference of the VAT system with national hybrid taxes and national real estate transfer taxes.
References
Békés B. & Halász Zs., Forgalmi Adók és a Vámjogi Szabályozás Alapjai, Wolters Kluwer, 2021, sec. 1.12.
Ebril et al.: The Modern VAT, IMF, Washington, 2011, p. 85.
Károlyi Balázs: The Compatibility of Turnover-Based Business Taxes with EU law and WTO law, IBFD Doctoral Series, Vol.73, pp. 83 et seq.
Károlyi Balázs: The EU VAT and the Expansion of Turnover Taxation: Interfering Tax Systems?, in: International VAT Monitor 2020 (Volume 31), No. 6. https://doi.org/10.59403/2by9r4c
V. Thuronyi: Comparative Tax Law, Kluwer Law International, 2003, pp. 54-55.
A. Musgrave & P. B. Musgrave: Public Finance in Theory and Practice, 5. kiadás, 1989, pp. 372-373.
Butor Gábor: Az építési telek fogalom meghatározásának kérdései az általános forgalmi adózás területén, Pázmány Law Working Papers, 2022/3. Elérhető: https://plwp.eu/images/2022/PLWP_2022_3-Butor.pdf